Recommendation to deny as presented with the hope that the building can be preserved based on the significance of this building and its existence on the National Register of Historic Places. It is important to the fabric of the neighborhood, the history of the flats, and the City.

The denial relates to the lack of evidence of the infeasibility to retain the building in a use that would allow it to continue.  The evidence would consist of an architectural engineering study, alternate plan, potential use, alternate cost estimate, market study, and pro forma to show that it is not feasible. 

Greg 1 

Krysta 2

Demolition of the elevator shaft & additions at the rear of the building is approved with meeting City of Cleveland Demolition Standards.

The main 4-storey structure is not to be demolished until further review with Landmarks, Economic Development, and City Planning, but is to be stabilized and made weather-tight. Doghouse and spiral staircase not to be demolished. Any future proposed demolition of the main structure must be re-presented to the Design Review Committee for review. 

Applicant is to review storage locker opportunities, Cuyahoga County pavement restrictions & utility connections. Applicant to preserve space for potential future elevator replacement as noted by Landmarks.

Committee strongly recommends maintaining the spiral staircase and doghouse that allow roof access for future maintenance, repair, inspections, and potential renovation efforts.

Motion to Approve with Conditions: Pay special attention to what is left on the existing building, so as not to cause any damage to it.